Saturday, 18 February 2012

How to Choose a Good Quality Dry Food (Kibble) for Dogs, Cats

In this article:
  1. General Issues and Your Dog's, Cat's Health
  2. Specific ingredients to Avoid - What, Why and How to Select a Better Quality Product
  3. How To Safely Transition Your Dog or Cat to Better Food 
  4. A Better Alternative to Dry and Wet Processed Commercial Food
  5. To Learn more
  6. Help Feed a Shelter Dog or Cat for Free

1.0 General Issues and Your Dog's, Cat's Health

I have to start out by saying that 'good dog or cat kibble' is a relative term. The point of this article is to assist you in choosing the best of what is available in dog and cat kibble, but...
  • I have to be 100% honest with you, I have yet to find a dog or cat kibble that is truly: 
    • Nutritionally complete;
    • Truly species appropriate; 
    • Truly free-of toxins and carcinogens. 
  • In addition it is important to note that no matter what dog kibble you purchase, in order to ensure your dog's or cat's overall health you will have to supplement his/her diet with other items such as:
    • Omega-3 Fatty Acids, and; 
    • Probiotics;
    • You will see why further below.  
    • But yes, there is a vast difference between the majority of dry dog food (dog kibble) and the truly better dry dog foods.
The number of obese dogs and cats has increased in recent years. As well, so many dogs and cats are getting cancer and other diseases. 

The proof is in the numbers;  
  • Statistics recorded by veterinary organizations from the 1950's up to present day are very telling;
  • The life-span of a companion dog in North America is now half of what it was in the 1950's;   
  •  In the 1950's the average life-span of a golden retriever was 15 to 16 years, today the average is in the range of 8 to12 years; 
  • In 2005, 50% of older dogs dies from cancer, and the number is on the rise.
 There are three main reasons for this downturn in the health of dogs and cats;
  • Inappropriate diet (the wrong type of food and food that contains toxins and carcinogens);
  • Lack of exercise,and; 
  • Environmental contaminants. 
Your dog’s and cat's best defense against cancer and other diseases is a strong immune system:
  • Diet plays a big role in a dog’s and cat's ability to maintain a healthy immune system. 
  • If you are feeding commercial dry or wet food (kibble), knowing how to choose a quality product is essential for your dog’s and cat's physical and mental health and well being;
  • And please don't make the mistake of assuming that the price of a  product is reflective of that products quality and safety - it is not. 
  • Of the many thousands of types dry and wet dog and cat foods and treats available there are very few that I recommend to my clients. 

2.0 Specific Ingredients to Avoid - What, Why and How
      To Choose a Better Product

Many commercial dog and cat kibbles are comprised of ingredients that are seriously bad for our companion animals. A kibble that provides poor nutritional value, contains cancer causing and otherwise toxic ingredients provides little hope of attaining and maintaining day-to-day energy and health. In addition toxins will build-up in a dog’s body overtime. This puts great strain on the organs - such as the liver and will eventually cause organ damage and failure. Poor quality nutrition can also lead to either being underweight or overweight / obese - either of which can also trigger the onset of disease. 

Just because a product is for sale in a pet supply store or on-line through a pet supply dealer don’t ever assume that the product is actually good for your dog or cat. Also, just because the manufacture labels the food as ‘natural’ or ‘holistic’, does not mean that the product is made up of good ingredients. 

'Natural' or 'holistic' are not regulated terms in the pet food industry - the product may simply mean the ingredients were derived from a plant or animal. In North America 'USDA  Certified Organic' is the only term that can actually be taken as a gurantee that the food does not contain:
  • Carcinogenic Fumigants;
  • Genetically Modified (GM) Ingredients, Genetically Engineered (GE) Ingredients;
  • Chemical Solvents;
  • Toxic Pesticides.
In addition, although the product may contain 1) fruit and vegetables, 2) probiotics...
1) The fruit and vegetables used:
  • May have been rotting - not fit for human consumption so they were used for pet food (there is no law currently in place that prevents a company from saying that the ingredients they are using in their kibble is first quality - they do not have to prove that this statement is true);
  • May be full of pesticides and herbicides.
2) The  'probiotics'  (i.e. Lb. acidophilus) used are rendered useless:
  • By the time the kibble is fully processed and ready the benefits that would normally be derived from fruit, vegetables and probiotics have been decimated by the processing process. 
To be effective, probiotics must be live. The beneficial micro-organisms and probiotics required by the GI tract are susceptible to heat damage. Most commercially made dry pet food is sterilised or pasteurized - canned food is prepared using dry heat. The only way in which the manufacturers can add probiotics to these foods is by coating the products with a liquid or powder after processing is complete. This presents two fundamental problems: the coating is inconsistent, and preservation of the probiotic is not possible with current technologies.

While I believe that fresh whole foods have much to offer your dog in the way of diverse nutrition to support overall health, boost the immune system, promote good oral health etc., once these foods have been commercially and highly processed overall value can be completely minimized.

Unknowingly you may be paying a manufacturer to seriously compromise the health and shorten the life of your dog and cat. On the other hand you may be feeding your dog and cat a very good  product. Unless you know a little more detail about how to discern true quality in a kibble product it is very difficult to identify good from bad. The same principles discussed in this article are also applicable to dog treats. I don't mince my words here becasue your dog's and cat's health and life depend upon someone speaking the truth.

Before we get into the detailed facts regarding what makes a food a good product or bad product , I just want to briefly address the issue of cost to the consumer - you!

Let’s Define ‘Quality’ In Broad Terms

In broad terms what is meant by ‘quality’ as pertains to this discussion? Well…

Just because the ingredients in a dog and cat food are said to be inspected by authorities having jurisdiction, i.e. CFIA (for Canada) or USDA (for USA) it is no reassurance that the product is truly a safe and nutritional food product for your dog. CFIA and the USDA allow great leeway in the inclusion of poor quality and toxic ingredients in pet foods.
    Also very important to note  -  just because a dog or cat food product  is AAFCO (Association of American Feed Control Officials)approved, does not mean that the food is a good or even safe to consume product. 
    • Although AAFCO promotes themselves as a 'governing' body of the pet food industry - they are self-proclaimed. 
    • While AAFCO does include some US state and federal representatives, AAFCO it is NOT a federal or state government organization. 
    • AAFCO is a partisan organization that includes people directly involved in the pet food manufacturing industry. 
    • AAFCO's true reason for existing is not to support the health of your dog, it exists to promote the pet food industry in its drive to produce the biggest possible margin of profit.  
    • AAFCO is directly responsible for the unclear labeling on pet food products including dry and wet dog food and treats;
    • AAFCO allows toxins and carcinogens into the food that they 'approve';
    • AAFCO is responsible for the confusion around poor vs. good quality.

    In my opinion a good 'Quality' dog or cat food:
    • Does NOT contain any non-species appropriate food stuffs;
    • Does not contain toxins and carcinogens;
    • Derives its protein, fat and carbs from truly good quality food stuffs;
    More on that further below...

    Does a Good Quality Kibble Really Cost you More than Poor Quality Kibble?

    I have seen many pet supply stores and large retailers selling a poor quality kibble for the same or more than they are selling a better quality kibble. And yes, better and really good quality kibbles may be more expensive to purchase at the cash register (than inexpensive kibbles) but the actual cost of these products is not necessarily higher once you get home and open that bag of food. 

    What do I mean by this statement? Well, a dog kibble that is comprised of poor quality ingredients offers less digestible high quality nutrition so you have to feed your dog  or cat considerably more kibble to at least part way met his/her nutritional needs than you would if the kibble was comprised of quality ingredients. You will go through a 40lb bag of poor quality kibble much faster than you will go through a 30lb bag of good quality kibble.

    Now Let’s Look at Good vs. Bad in Detail

    What we really want to make sure of is that we don’t purchase product a) comprised of  poor quality nutrition, b) minimize the carcinogens and other toxic components.

    Synthetic Additives, Preservatives & Colouring Agents
    Many off-the-shelf dog foods and treats contain synthetic additives, preservatives and colouring - many are proven carcinogens. These substances are added to the kibble to help stabilize the product and enhance its appearance. The most common of these preservatives are BHA, BHT, EQ (ethoxyquin), propyl gallate. You can read more about preservatives to avoid here. Then there are artificial colouring agents and additives such as glycerol monostearate, phosphoric acid and propylene glycol (this is used in antifreeze - antifreeze kills dogs!). Read product labels - if the product you are looking at contains these ingredients put it back on the shelf! Instead look for products that contain ‘natural preservatives’ and antioxidants such as Vitamin C, Vitamin E, and mixed tocopherols.
    Minimize the Poor Nutrition and the ‘Unknown’ in Your Dog’s Diet
    Once again, many off-the-shelf dog and cat foods contain food stuffs from unknown sources. These food stuffs are cheap source fillers that provide poor quality nutrition and can be full of unknown chemicals, steroids and antibiotics, petroleum derivatives, aflatoxins, etc. 

    Grains and Poor Quality Legumes
    In the 1950's the percentage of grain products used in kibble increased dramatically and has since continued to reign as the most common ingredient in commercially manufactured dog kibble. Many of these grain products are added primarily as fillers. 

    Two of the most commonly used grains /legumes are corn and soy - both GMO in North America and both seriously damaging to your dog's and cat's health.

    These products are included:
    • For the benefit of the manufacture’s cost margin and profit, not for the benefit of your dog or cat;
    • To help bind the ingredients in kibble together.
    Not only are grains not a species appropriate food for a dog or cat, the digestibility and nutrition available from many grain products is negligible. Your dog and cat ends up consuming a lot of filler with very little nutrient value. This is very deceptive as you think you are feeding your dog and cat enough and his stools are sizable (due to the high filler indigestible fibre content), but his nutrient intake is low. Here is a list of some of these low nutrient, cheap fillers…brewers rice, cereal food fines (leftovers from human grade cereal production -  junk), feeding oat meal, grain fermentation soluble, maltodextrins, fermentation solubles, potato product (leftovers from human grade potato product production - nutritional value, nil), soy flour, corn bran, corn cellulose, oat hulls, peanut hulls, rice hulls, soybean and wheat mill run (wheat middlings), corn germ meal, corn gluten meal, soybean meal (these last three ingredients are often included as a source of protein - very poor quality protein!).

    While some of these fillers are derived from the leftovers of human food processing - as the product at the end of the line, they can be full of chemicals. They can also be from non-human grade sources. If the grains/grain derivatives are not from human grade sources they will contain aflatoxins. Aflatoxins cause liver cancer. Aflatoxins grow mainly on grains but they also grow on legumes - like peanuts, walnuts and pecans. This is one reason why you will hear some people say do not give your dogs nuts! Actually it is fine to give your dog peanuts or peanut butter - they are a good source of nutrition - just make sure you are giving them human grade. 

    Aflatoxins can also be found in cottonseed oil, fish meal and peanut oil. Human grade foods are monitored closely for aflatoxins, if they are present the raw product (such as grain) is not allowed to be sold as human grade. There are no such regulations for animal grade foods so aflatoxins so most commercial grade dog, cat and bird food will have some aflatoxins...the body can usually detoxify small amounts. 

    Rye is another grain that can cause problems for your dog. Rye contains polysaccharides (classified as a type of carbohydrate and biological polymer, starch and cellulose). The problem is not that rye contains this substance but the fact that it contains a high content of polysaccharides (i.e. in comparison with other grains such as wheat and corn). Why is that bad? Well polysaccharides interfere with the body's ability to utilize nutrients. Additionally, rye contains alkylresorcinol in high levels - this substance is a known to irritate intestinal and mucous membranes and can also retard growth.
    Another thing to consider…
    • Corn and soybeans in the USA and Canada are almost all grown from Genetically Modified (GM) seeds - the long term affect of ingesting GM food is not known. 
    • Further to this, large factory farms use a method to process soy that leaves it very high in photoestrogens. 
      • Photoestrogens have been proven to interfere with reproduction and thyroid function. Factory farming processing methods for soy also result in a product that is very high in phytates. 
      • Phytates prevent mineral absorption as well as substances that prevent the normal function of enzymes required to digest protein.  
      • Traditional methods of processing soy by fermentation (as employed in Japan and China) greatly reduces photoestrogens, and phytates, thus making consumption of the resulting soy, safe and nutritional. 
    • And one last thumbs down for large factory farm produced soy - it has one of the highest concentrations of pesticides found in North American crops. 
      • For example, large factory farm soybean crops receive heavy applications of the potent herbicide glyphosate -  a powerful toxin and carcinogen. 
      • The vast majority of soy derivatives (i.e. soybean oil, soy meal, soy milk, tofu and everything in-between) found in both feedstock and human food is contaminated with high amounts of glyphosate. 
    Look for off-the-shelf dog food that specifies that the ingredients are from first grade or human grade sources.  

    Grains are not part of a dog's natural diet! This includes whole corn kernels and corn derivatives (i.e. corn bran, corn cellulose, corn meal are just fillers offering little nutritional value if any). While rice offer better nutritional digestibility than many of the grain products noted above…rice is also not species appropriate food. Sweet potatoes, legumes such as chickpeas and lentils and squash are a better and nutrient dense source of carbohydrates. 

    High quality fiber such as the fiber from fresh fruits and vegetables is very different from the low quality fiber found in many off-the-shelf dog food products. Again, low grade fiber is added as cheap filler for the benefit of the manufacture’s cost margin and profit, not for the benefit of your dog. Cellulose derived from dried, processed wood is the most common form of cellulose (hard to believe but true!), corn bran (GM product), oat hulls, peanut hulls, rice hulls, soybean middlings (GM product) and wheat middlings. These ingredients may also contain aflatoxins. If the product has a lot of these ingredients put it back on the shelf. Veterinarian prescribed dog and cat food is notorious for containing these fillers. A perfect example of when cost is NOT a reflection of quality, and in-fact you can be paying a lot of money to seriously endanger the health of your dog. Another example of just how badly many prescription foods can be - you can take a look at section 7.0 of this article - what you see will shock you.

    Protein should be the first ingredient in your dogs kibble…but there are issues to be aware of with protein sources too. Protein may come from poultry (chicken, duck, etc.), cattle, swine, lamb…the problem is often what goes into the kibble is not the quality cuts of meat - lean muscle tissue. Instead the animal parts that are added to a lot of kibble is the by-products - the bones, blood, intestines, ligaments, and many other parts not sold for human consumption. Here is a list of protein sources that you should avoid - again, if these are listed in the product, put it back on the shelf…beef and bone meal, blood meal, chicken by-product meal, corn distillers dried grains with solubles, corn germ meal, corn gluten meal, fish meal, liver meal, meat and bone meal, meat meal, pork and bone meal, poultry by-product meal, poultry meal and soybean meal. As these ingredients are loosely regulated they may be from 4-D animals (dead, diseased, disabled, or dying prior to slaughter), road-kill, animals euthanized at ‘shelters’ (euthanization includes the use of harmful chemicals, also the animals may have been diseased), the ingredients may also include pus, cancerous tissue, decomposing tissue, etc.

    Fish Meal
    If the kibble you are feeding your dog or cat contains fish meal - I would advise you to do some serious research to make sure that the manufacturer states that their products ARE ethoxyquin-free.  You will not see ethoxyquin listed under ingredients on dog and cat food labels as ethoxyquin is an ingredient in an ingredient - meaning it is added to fish meal and the fish meal is then added to the food. You will have to either call the manufacture or do a search on their website or on the internet to see if you can find a disclaimer where the manufacturer gurantees that their product is ethoxyquin-free.

    Many pet food manufacturers purchase their fish meal from processing plants that put ethoxyquin into the fish meal. Ethoxyquin - is a pesticide that is also used in animal feed to stop fats from going rancid. Ethoxyquin is a very dangerous substance - it IS a known carcinogen, allergen and more. Due to its extreme health hazard, ethoxyquin has been banned from use in human food. To understand more about this dangerous substance and why you do NOT want it in your dog's or cat's food you can read more here.

    The Diamond Pet Foods is a perfect example of a manufacturer that continues to use fish meal with ethoxyquin. Some of the products manufactured by Diamond Pet Foods are - Taste of the Wild, Costco's Kirkland Lake Dog and Cat food, Diamond, Diamond Naturals. Diamond has also had a lot of pet food product recalls.

    Animal and poultry fat is added to a lot of kibble. Again these are the rancid fats and oil by products that are not sold for human consumption. Waste from restaurants and food manufacturing is saved and then refined by rendering companies, who then turn around and sell it to pet food manufactures. The manufactures add them to their poor quality kibble to give it taste and to help the ingredients bind together. The following are the ingredients you should avoid…animal fat, beef tallow, lard, poultry fat, vegetable oil. Again the source of these fats can also be from 4-D animals and the vegetable oil is likely to be poor quality and/or GM.

    Sweeteners are not required in your dog’s or cat's diet! In fact they are not good for your dog or cat. They are added to many pet foods to make the food more attractive - think about it, some of these products have a lot of fillers - no taste…so the sweeteners give the food some taste. If the product you are going to buy has these ingredients you know want to do - re-shelve it: cane molasses, corn syrup, fructose, sorbitol, sugar, di-alpha tocopherol acetate. Remember daily intake of sweeteners is just as bad for dogs as it is for humans. Sugar suppresses the immune system - making it easier for cancer to take hold. Sweeteners also cause allergies, arthritis, cataracts, hypoglycaemia, heart ailments, nervous energy, tooth decay, obesity and so on. The more your dog’s and cat's health is compromised the harder it is for your dog’s and cat's body to fight diseases including cancer, to fight off insects and parasites and so on.  If you would like to see a more comprehensive list of ingredients to avoid you can click here.

    Sugar, syrup and molasses are all health threats to your companion animal - these sugars are a double health threat...
    • Due to their inflammatory properties;
    • Typically the sweeteners used in dog and cat food are not quality products;
      • Sugar beets in North America are a genetically modified (GMO) genetically engineered food;
      • So, much like the Round-up Ready Corn and soy, GMO sugar beets are high in pesticide residue and may cause acquired cell mutation in dogs and cats.
      • Although sugar from sugar cane is not GMO, it is an inflammatory;
      • Sugar from corn is a GMO, GE product, high in pesticide residue, and has been proven to cause the growth of tumors;
        • Syrup and molasses are both made from sugar;
      • Raw Unpasturized Honey is the only sweetener that provides health benefits for dogs and cats BUT the beneficial properties of honey are destroyed by pasteurization, by heating and cooking. 
        • If a dog or cat food or treat contains honey - the honey becomes a health threatening sweetener if it was:
          • a pasturized honey;
          • if the food or treat has been heat processed.

    3.0 How to Safely Transition Your Dog, Cat to New Food

    If you are going to switch your dog’s kibble don’t switch his food overnight.
    Add a little of the new food to the old food. Gradually increase the amount of new food and decrease the amount of old food until the old is completely replaced by new. This process should be carried out over several days to several weeks depending on the hardiness of your dog’s and cat's digestive system. Some dogs and cats are very sensitive to changes in their diet while others dogs are not.

    If you have switched your dog’s or cat's food before with no deleterious affects and you know your dog’s system is hardy you can shorten the phasing in of the new food. 

    If you want to see some examples of bad, better and good dry dog food you can read this article.The strictures noted on the article also pertain to cat food.

    4.0 A Better Alternative to Dry and Wet Commercial Food

    You Can Also Make Your Own Dog and Cat Food and Treats
    If you would like to try making healthy, nutritious home-made dog and cat food to either supplement or completely phase-out dog or cat kibble you can try these home made recipes I developed for the health of my dogs and cats...
    Homemade Cooked Food Recipe
    Homemade Chicken or Meat Broth
    5.0 To Learn More

    To Learn More About Enriching Your Dog's Diet
    You can explore ma wealth of information in my many articles on dog and cat diet, nutrition, health and care here.

    To Learn More About Discerning Good vs. Bad Kibble
    If you would like to look at the subject (of what makes a kibble good or bad) in further depth I recommend that you take a look at the Dog Food Project’s website section on Commercial Dry Foods.

    An Independent Review of 100's of Brands and Types of Kibble
    If you would like to see an extensive listing of Dry Dog Food reviewed by an independent group I you can take a look at the Dog Food Advisor’s website page on Dry Dog Food. I don't really like the site myself as it does not educate people regarding the real issues at hand - what makes a good food for a dog or cat. Why do I say that? The site does not address the most basic of elements that can make a food good or bad - for example:
    • Grain-in foods are not rated as inappropriate for the species canine, feline;
    • The many toxic, carcinogenic, short and long term threats posed by grains are not explained;
    • Yes a dry food may have a high meat-porotein content but if the animal from which that meat was obtained (i.e. chicken, cow, etc) was feed GMO corn, was injected with growth hormones, steroids, antibiotics - your dog or cat is ingesting the hormones, steroids, antibiotics, etc. This is one of the reasons for the explosion of thyroid problems, antibiotic resistance and high rates of cancer in our companion animals.
    • There is no mention of omega insufficiency in these foods or of the poor source of the fats - i.e. from a GMO plant crop;
    • Non-viable ingredients such as probiotics are not addressed - good bacteria) micro-organisms) cannot survive the processing required to create dry dog food.
    • Etc.  

    6.0 Holistic Support

    Holistic Wellness Services and Holistic Behaviorist Services 

    Holistic Wellness and Behaviorist Services

    Do you need holistic advice to support your companion animal's health and well being? Become a client. Book your consultation. My professional holistic nutrition, wellness and behavioral services are available to you:
    🌿 Holistic Wellness Services for Dogs and Cats πŸ• 🐈
    🌿 Holistic Behaviorist Services for Dogs πŸ•

    My Holistic Client Services are Available Worldwide:
    πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ USA
    πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ Canada
    πŸ‡¬πŸ‡§ UK and other European countires
    πŸ‡¦πŸ‡Ί Australia and other Oceania countires
    πŸ‡­πŸ‡° Hong Kong and other Asian countries
    πŸ‡¨πŸ‡· Costa Rica and other Central American countries 
    πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡Ί European countries
    πŸ‡ΉπŸ‡Ή Trinidad and Tobago and other South America countries
    πŸ‡ΏπŸ‡¦ South Africa and other African countries
    πŸ‡ΈπŸ‡ͺ Sweden and other european countries
    πŸ‡¦πŸ‡ͺ United Arab Emirates

    Available Holistic Consultations and Sessions:
    πŸ“± FaceTime
    πŸ“± Facebook video or voice calling
    πŸ’» Skype
    πŸ“ž Phone
    πŸ“§ Email 
    🚢🏻‍♀️ In-Person

    Menu of Holistic Wellness Services for Dogs and Cats πŸ•πŸˆ
    For more information go here. 
    ✅  Maintain Health, and;
    ✅  Address Health Issues and Conditions:
    ✓ Treatment and Remedy 
     Pre-Surgery holistic support protocols
     Post-Surgery holistic healing protocols
     Pre-Vaccine holistic support protocols 
     Post-Vaccine holistic support protocols
     Natural Insect and Parasite Prevention
     Natural Treatment for Insect, Parasite Infestation, Co-Infection, Disease
    ✅  Custom Designed Whole Food Diets - raw or gently cooked, and;
    ✅  Advice and Recommendation: 
    ✓ Premade Diets - raw, dehydrated, freeze dried 
    ✓ Supplemental Fresh Foods - raw, gently cooked
    ✓ Super foods
    ✓ Treats - raw, dehydrated, freeze dried, gently cooked
    ✓ Herbs 
    ✓ Alternative Medicines

    Menu of Holistic Behaviorist Services for Dogs πŸ•
    For more information go here
    In-person Sessions - available locally
    Voice and Video Sessions - available worldwide 
    ✓   Obedience Training
    ✓   Behavior Modification
    ✓   Psychological Rehabilitation

    Affiliations to Companies
    ✓ None.
    ✓ I don't sell food or supplements.
    ✓ I'm not aligned with any companies.
    ✓ I choose to maintain my objectivity in selecting best-solutions for my individual client's needs.

    Article and graphics by Karen Rosenfeld 

    7.0 Help Feed a Shelter Dog or Cat for Free
    You can do so by clicking on the following links…when you go to these sites and click on the button corporate sponsors donate kibble to homeless pets on your behalf. I click on all three sites every day.

    The Animal Rescue Site


    1. Wow. Tons of great information. We recently switched our dogs (and cats) to Life's Abundance, because the more we researched what goes into the pet food the more we realized that we had to find an alternative and we don't have time to cook for them and I worry that the food we cook wouldn't give them everything they needed.

      I've noticed reps from the premium pet brands hanging out at the pet food stores and one told me that their food was so great that it wasn't necessary to get the dogs used to it - WRONG. I just gave our dogs a little bit to see how they liked it and they paid for it later that day in the yard.

      Now I do my homework before adding something to our pets' diets.

    2. Hello - here is the ingredients list for the food I feed my Chessie - she has had skin flakiness and rough coat issues and since we switched her to this and supplemented with omega 3 pills daily it has made a huge difference. I was wondering if you could have a peek at teh ingredients and tell me what you think.
      Chicken meal, chicken, brown rice, oatmeal, dehulled barley, chicken fat (preserved with mixed tocopherols – source of vitamin e), natural chicken flavour, tomatoes, whole dried egg, herring meal, flaxseed, salmon oil (source of dha), brewer’s yeast, whole sweet potatoes, whole carrots, whole blueberries, whole cranberries, whole apples, calcium carbonate, potassium chloride, dicalcium phosphate, sodium chloride, chicory root, choline chloride, vitamins & chelated minerals (vitamin a, vitamin d3, vitamin e, niacin, vitamin c, inositol, d-calcium pantothenate, thiamine mononitrate, Riboflavin, beta-carotene, pyridoxine hydrochloride, folic acid, vitamin k, biotin, vitamin b12, zinc proteinate, ferrous sulphate, iron proteinate, zinc oxide, copper proteinate, copper sulphate, manganese proteinate, manganous oxide, calcium iodate, sodium selenite), probiotics (lactobacillus acidophilus, lactobacillus casei, enterococcus faecium, bifidobacterium thermophilum), dl-methionine, yucca schidigera, dried rosemary. .

      1. Hi Karen,

        This food has multiple issues...

        1) The food includes grain - the issues with grain are described in the article above. Grains such as rice, oatmeal and barley are species inappropriate and can cause major health issues in dogs and cats. Aflatoxin (described in the article above) is also found on animal feed-grade rice, oatmeal and barley.
        If the manufacturer makes a grain-free version of the food you would be much better off switching to that.

        The food contain fish meal - in this case herring meal. Find out if the manufacturer states that the fish meal is ethoxyquin-free, if it is not, then the fish meal is carcinogenic.

        The food includes chelated minerals - make sure that they do not come from China, as contamination with toxins is a high possibility.

        The probiotics included are a waste as they are all dead and there for not viable.

        dl-methionine can be contaminated with toxins.

    3. How do these ingredients look?

      Boneless chicken*, chicken meal, chicken liver*, whole herring*, boneless turkey*, turkey meal, turkey liver*, whole eggs*, boneless walleye*, whole salmon*, chicken heart*, chicken cartilage*, herring meal, salmon meal, chicken liver oil, red lentils, green peas, green lentils, sun-cured alfalfa, yams*, pea fiber, chickpeas, pumpkin*, butternut squash*, spinach greens*, carrots*, Red Delicious apples*, Bartlett pears*, cranberries*, blueberries*, kelp, licorice root, angelica root, fenugreek, marigold, sweet fennel, peppermint leaf, chamomile, dandelion, summer savory, rosemary, Enterococcus faecium.

      Anything with a * is fresh when made and preservative free - including ethoxyquin- . The probiotic is added AFTER the cooking process, I think that makes some of a difference. All the ingredients are local - Canadian.

      The brands called Orijen - looks promising.

      1. Champion Pet Foods makes both Orijen and Acana. The grain-free products are one of the few dry food products that I do recommend to clients. Orijen and Acana do not contain ethoxyquin, some of the products like the one you chose above is GMO oil free, etc. If you want to use dry dog food it is one of the better choices.

      2. Anonyomus, I agree w/Karen. She is a very knowledgeable woman. I have tried Acana and my dogs loved it!!! It is high in meat protein, 70% I think. It claims to use all locally sourced free range meat & fish. I believe the veg. and fruit are organic. I want to get it again for our two Golden Retrievers but recently bought a local brand; Dave's Grain Free Chicken. Dave's is made here in MA, USA. though not fancy, or organic it lists Chicken meal first; then..... tapioca starch, field pea, chicken fat,(preserved with mixed tocopherols, natural source of vitamin E),carrots, celery ,beets, parsley, water crest, spinach, flax seed, natural flavor, fish oil, chicken cartilage, salt, potassium chloride ,DL Methionne, calcium carbonate, choline chloride,L-lycine, acidophilus product dehydrated, pumpkin meal, rosemary powder, ground thyme, ground cumin, mustard seed powder, crushed red chili pepper, Fructoligosaccharide, Glucosamine, Vit E Supplement, and other vitamins. Now I am wondering, after the chicken meal, veggies & flax seed, what other of these ingredients are beneficial? I would like to ask Karen this . Does she charge for an email answer? I appreciate your response. Thanks! I have exhausted my money for the month.

      3. Acana does not use organic ingredients. Acana is made by Champion Pet Food - they make a better product called Orijin. Acana and Orijin do not use organic ingredients. Orijin is a better food than the dry dog foods that do use organic ingredients - as those foods are primarily grain-in and the organic portion of the food is grain. Only buy grain-free Acana or Orijin products.

        Bad news for you re Dave's product...

        Dave's is very high in fillers - i.e. second ingredient in the product - Tapioca starch
        What It Is
        `Tapioca is derived from the cassava bean;
        Tapioca is an inexpensive filler;
        An inexpensive source of fibre;

        Why It is Used
        Tapioca is readily available and inexpensive;
        It increases the volume of the food;
        And is an inexpensive source of carbohydrates;
        Gluten free, so Tapioca can be used as an alternative to wheat flour when the presence of gluten can exacerbate a health condition.
        High in Calories and is associated with weight gain;
        Contains almost no nutrients;
        Tapioca that has not undergone proper processing can cause cyanide poisoning;

        Dave's is critically low in protein derived from meat - evidenced by the presence of DL Methionne, a synthetic version of Methionne a naturally occurring essential amino acid necessary for dogs, and sourced from meat.

        Dave's is a rip-off and actually costs you more than Orijen as you must feed your dog more of Dave's high in filler, low in nutritional value food.

        You will save money in the long and short term (spend less on food, spend less on vet bills and have your dog live a longer and healthier life) if you switch to homemade dog food with this recipe

        Cheers, Karen

    4. I recently came across this food. I have never seen it before and was curious how it stacked up in your expertise.
      The ingredients are:

      Organic Chicken, Chicken Meal, Deboned Turkey, Turkey Meal, Potatoes, Chickpeas, Chicken Fat (Naturally Preserved with Mixed Tocopherols), Fresh Whole Sweet Potatoes, Alfalfa Sprouts, Pumpkin, Pea Fiber, Fresh Whole Carrots, Dulse, Sea Salt, Whole Blueberries, Whole Cranberries, Potassium Chloride, Spinach, Tomato, Beets, Parsley, Chicory Root Extract, Sage, Basil, Apple Cider Vinegar, Green Tea Extract, DHA, Ginger, Primrose Oil, Glucosamine, Chondroitin, Colostrum, Blue Green Algae, Dl Methionine, Vitamin A Acetate, Vitamin E Supplement, Riboflavin Supplement, Vitamin B-12 Supplement, Coral Calcium, Vitamin D, Magnesium, Niacin Supplement, Choline chloride, Pyridoxine Hydrochloride, Thiamine Mononitrate, Folic Acid, Vitamin C, Biotin, Inositol, Omega 3 / Omega 6 Oils, Polysaccharide Complexes of Zinc, Iron, Manganese, Copper and Cobalt, Calcium lodate, Sodium Selenite, Yucca Schidigera Extract, Pectin, Lactobacillus Acidophilus Fermentation Product Dehydrated, Lactobacillus Casei, Enterococcus Faecium Fermentation Product Dehydrated, B. Subtillus, Bacillus Lichenformis, Bacillus Coagulins, Aspergillus Oryzae and Aspergillus Niger

      1. Hi Sarah,

        Although the food contains some nice ingredients - most of those ingredients have lost their value due to the processing required to make the food. At $30.00/10 pounds it is a waste of $.

        The add Dl Methionine, a sure sign that there was not enough meat in the recipe in the first place and that the amino acids in the meat have been severely degraded during processing. Colostrum and the bacterial strains (last 3 lines of ingredients) are non-viable. Same is true for the apple cider vinegar - which was not organic and not unpasturized so even fresh would have been useless. The Omega 3 content is very low. There is not enough chondriotin in the food to have any healthful effect.

        This food gets a thumbs down for being an over-priced, underachieving and misleading product.

        Cheers, K

    5. Hi Karen,

      Do you know Fromm's grain free dog kibbles? I generally cook some ground turkey, sweet potatoes, green beans, spinach, and peas, mix it with Fromm's beef or salmon kibble, and add ground egg shells and a pet kelp that contains condroitin. I hope that I am covering the bases for his nutritional needs doing this.

      1. Yes I am familiar with Fromm`s. When feeding dry kibble you should add foods that add value to your dogs diet - not foods create additional health risk. Starch on top of starch - Fromm;s has many starchy ingredients. Calcium on top of calcium and iron on top of iron. In addition your dog`s diet is critically low on Omega-3 fatty acids as well his diet is missing other essentials for good health. So no you are not covering his nutritional needs with the kibble or with the items you are adding.

    6. My German shepherd has been eating "raw" for her whole life. She is usually taken for a much younger dog, at her near 9 years, and has had virtually no health issues. With two other pups joining our home, I have been seriously changing Hannah over to kibble, for both budget and convenience. After studying much of this website, I don't think I can do it! My original rational for maintaining the raw diet was that it would actually be less expensive in the long run, with her better health. Hmm. I'm coming full circle! I look forward to working with these receipes to make less expensive and more healthy food. Many thanks.

    7. Thanks! It is all so confusing. What kibble might you suggest for a dog with fowl allergies. We are currently using Annamaet Option 24

      Ingredient List:

      Salmon Meal, Brown Rice, Venison Meal, Millet, Rolled Oats, Pearled Barley, Canola Oil, Menhaden Oil (Preserved with Natural Mixed Tocopherols (Vitamin E)), Dried Tomato Pomace, Flax Seed Meal, Carrot, Celery, Parsley, Lettuce, Watercress, Spinach, Lecithin, Salt, DL Methionine, L-Lysine, Propionic Acid, Vitamin E Supplement, L-Ascorbyl-2-Polyphosphate (source of Vitamin C), Niacin Supplement, Biotin, Thiamine Mononitrate, L-Carnitine, d-Calcium Pantothenate, Riboflavin Supplement, Pyridoxine Hydrochloride, Vitamin A Acetate, Vitamin B12 Supplement, Vitamin D3 Supplement, Folic Acid, Choline Chloride, Potassium Chloride, Zinc Proteinate, Betaine Anhydrous, Iron Proteinate, Selenium Yeast, Copper Proteinate, Manganese Proteinate, Calcium Iodate.

    8. Hi Karen,
      I sent a question a while back but I don't seem to have gotten a reply. Have you checked out TLC dog kibble? Is it all it claims to be?

      1. See item 6.0 in the article above or go here

    9. My dog is husky/lab mix 11years old. He has a fatty tumor that is getting larger on his upper hip area. My vet did a needle biopsy and it is not cancer. I am trying to figure out if I should change food. Currently feeding dry kibble. 4 Health White Fish and Potato-Whitefish, Fish Meal, Pea Protein, Dried Peas, Tapioca, Whole Potato, Sunflower Oil (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols, a source of Vitamin E), Dried Plain Beet Pulp, Whole Flaxseed, Natural Flavor, Salt, Potassium Chloride, Fish Oil (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols, a source of Vitamin E), Zinc Proteinate, Vitamin E Supplement, Iron Proteinate, L-Ascorbyl-2-Polyphosphate (source of Vitamin C), Choline Chloride, Manganese Proteinate, L-Carnitine, Copper Proteinate, Niacin, D-Calcium Pantothenate, Biotin, Sodium Selenite, Vitamin D3 Supplement, Riboflavin Supplement, Thiamine Mononitrate, Vitamin A Supplement, Vitamin B12 Supplement, Calcium Iodate, Pyridoxine Hydrochloride (source of Vitamin B6), Folic Acid.

      1. 1. If you want to halt the growth of the lipoma and reverse it you MUST change your dog's food and healthy regimen.

        2. The food you propose to feed your dog contains multiple toxins which will simply serve to fed the lipoma.

        3. You can try to address the lipoma on your own.

        4. Or you can engage my diet nutrition wellness service to have me design a custom holistic diet nutrition wellness plan to address the lipoma. I do a lot of diets for dogs with lipoma.

        I recommend that you read about lipomas here

    10. Hi Karen-

      Could you give me your imput on 4Health Grain Free Witefish and Potato food, ingredients below. I want to make sure i'm feeding my rot mix something healthy but don't have the budget to buy some of the more expensive alternatives. Any suggestions? Thanks!

      Whitefish, Fish Meal, Pea Protein, Dried Peas, Tapioca, Whole Potato, Sunflower Oil (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols, a source of Vitamin E), Dried Plain Beet Pulp, Whole Flaxseed, Natural Flavor, Salt, Potassium Chloride, Fish Oil (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols, a source of Vitamin E), Zinc Proteinate, Vitamin E Supplement, Iron Proteinate, L-Ascorbyl-2-Polyphosphate (source of Vitamin C), Choline Chloride, Manganese Proteinate, L-Carnitine, Copper Proteinate, Niacin, D-Calcium Pantothenate, Biotin, Sodium Selenite, Vitamin D3 Supplement, Riboflavin Supplement, Thiamine Mononitrate, Vitamin A Supplement, Vitamin B12 Supplement, Calcium Iodate, Pyridoxine Hydrochloride (source of Vitamin B6), Folic Acid.

      1. If the fish is not wild or wild caught I would strongly advise against giving this product - you can read my articles on fish in dog food. If the fish meal contains any preservatives - fail. Added salt - fail. natural flavour = toxins and carcinogens - fail. Product is high in cheap fillers - peas - fail. Where are the vitamins and minerals sourced from - if from China - fail.

    11. hi Karen, have you heard of Ziwipeak? it is air dried raw meat. I was thinking of swapping my maltese to this from Acana senior as she is having skin and ear problems all of a sudden. I am a bit unsure as it is high in protein and fat than what she is used to.

      1. Yes I have, and I do not recommend it to my patience, but I don't recommend Acana either.

    12. Hi Karen - absolutely love this blog. What do you think of the 'Wellness' brand kibble ? We're giving this to our 2 year old yellow lab. This is a grain-free product due to her condition where she was forming crystals in her urine, originally thinking she had a urinary tract infection. Thanks
      Andy & Lisa

      Deboned Chicken, Chicken Meal, Turkey Meal, Potatoes, Peas, Tomato Pomace, Dried Ground Potatoes, Ground Flaxseed, Chicken Fat (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols), Natural Chicken Flavor, Pea Fiber, Potassium Chloride, Spinach, Broccoli, Vitamin E Supplement, Carrots, Parsley, Apples, Blueberries, Kale, Sweet Potatoes, Taurine, L-Carnitine, Mixed Tocopherols added to preserve freshness, Zinc Proteinate, Glucosamine Hydrochloride, Chondroitin Sulfate, Zinc Sulfate, Calcium Carbonate, Niacin, Ferrous Sulfate, Iron Proteinate, Beta-Carotene, Vitamin A Supplement, Copper Sulfate, Thiamine Mononitrate, Copper Proteinate, Manganese Proteinate, Manganese Sulfate, d-Calcium Pantothenate, Sodium Selenite, Pyridoxine Hydrochloride, Chicory Root Extract, Yucca Schidigera Extract, Riboflavin, Vitamin D3 Supplement, Biotin, Calcium Iodate, Vitamin B12 Supplement, Folic Acid, Ascorbic Acid (Vitamin C), Dried Lactobacillus plantarum Fermentation Product, Dried Enterococcus faecium Fermentation Product, Dried Lactobacillus casei Fermentation Product, Dried Lactobacillus acidophilus Fermentation Product, Rosemary Extract, Green Tea Extract, Spearmint Extract.

      1. Wellness kibble is not a recipe for Wellness - it is an inflammatory food product

    13. Hi, I want to thank you for the wealth of information you share on your site. I have a recently-rescued dog with multiple lipomas. Currently I feed her Acana with a raw egg, tbs of organic kefir, and tsp olive oil in the morning and then substitute the egg for sardine at night. I will get her back onto raw when I start making more money again (and will switch to Orijen now), and will be switching out the olive oil for the coconut oil/turmeric mix in each meal, thanks to your provided information.

      My last two dogs were strictly raw, so I'm looking forward to getting back there with this girl.

      I go to a holistic vet and will share your site with her.

      Thank you.

    14. Hi, what about the heavy metals in Acana and Orijen? Also, I have a pug who constantly scoots on Orijen for some reason

      1. All highly processed pet 'food' products cause health issues. There is no truly 'good' highly processed pet 'foods'. I recommend feeding real whole food - raw or gently cooked nutritionally complete diets. You can find articles on this blog on feeding real whole fresh raw or gently cooked food diets.


    Important Note

    1.0 Use of Foods, Herbs, Alternative Medicines:

    Safe use of items and protocols in the article above, is your sole responsibility.

    Foods, herbs and alternative medicines have health issue, condition and conventional drug interactions. Safe use of all substances and protocol are your responsibility.

    Before you use any substance or protocol do your research. Check for cautions, contradictions, interactions and side effects. Do not use substances or protocols not suitable to your animal's individual circumstances.

    If your animal has an underlying condition substances and protocols may conflict.

    2.0 Definition of Holistic…

    Food, herbs, alternative medicines are NOT ‘holistic’ they are a substance and MAY, or may NOT be ‘NATURAL’.

    If you use a ‘natural’ substance (ie. an herb) you are using a natural substance, not a holistic substance.

    Holistic is not defined by use of one or several substances. Holistic is an approach.

    Definition of “holistic” from the Cambridge Advanced Learner's Dictionary & Thesaurus © Cambridge University Press


    "relating to the whole of something or to the total system instead of just to its parts"

    "Holistic medicine attempts to treat the whole person, including mind and body, not just the injury or disease."

    Holistic is a way of approaching life, and within that health, and well-being.

    3.0 Expectation a natural substance remedies a health or behavioral situation.

    A natural substance used to treat symptoms. But, if factors causing the underlying issue remain you do not have a remedy.

    Remedy requires a comprehensive approach. It is necessary to identify root cause. Remove items that trigger, cause or otherwise contribute to issues. Holistic approach includes design, implementation to treat, remedy and maintain long-term health.

    4.0 Leave a Comment

    I review all comments and publish those deemed appropriate for this site.

    I answer questions deemed appropriate when I have time to do so.

    Wishing your dog and cat the best of health!

    Karen Rosenfeld
    Ottawa Valley Dog Whisperer
    Holistic Behaviorist - Dogs
    Holistic Diet Nutrition Wellness Adviser – Dogs and Cats